Season 1
Each episode takes the Grammy Award singer Natalie Grant to a church to match up one of their eligible singles. The church and pastor pick the guinea pig, who then consents. Various "matchmakers" in the church nominate eligible dates, someone they think would be good, and describes before the church why they picked the candidate. The church then narrows the field down to 3 finalists through ballot voting.
01. Charlotte
Natalie Grant hosts as members of a Christian congregation play matchmaker in this competition to help a single parishioner find love. During the premiere episode, a Charlotte, NC bachelorette is lead through an obstacle course by each bachelor.
02. Brooklyn
Social worker Denise Michel had her heart broken, but found joy again with this congregation and is now ready to find love.
03. Baltimore
Iquasia has fallen for liars and players in the past, but now she's hoping to change her luck at church.
04. Goshen
After a devastating illness knocked her out of the dating world for 2 years, Nicole hopes to get back out there.
05. Milwaukee
Sweet single mom Hilary, committed to her 2 year old, has stopped making time for herself.
06. Rock Hill
Single mother and reformed party girl Valeria has stayed away from men for years, but is ready to give it a try again.
07. Oxnard
Shawna is a teacher whose busy work life has shut down her love life.
08. Tempe
A very special episode featuring a bachelor, Randy, who is trying to get past a family tragedy and start a real relationship.